[sword-devel] Versification discovery? [Was: Re: French versifications, was Re: FreJND and HebDelitzsch released]

[Greg Hellings]

So what that's telling you is that your module has a strict subset of
all of those versioning schemes. "Your file has no extra references"
means that there are no attributes named "osisID" that exist in your
module that do not exist in the specified versification system. That
it reports such for ALL of the versification schemes seems a little
bit suspect, but it could be possible (only if the module is purely
OT-only, which a brief glance through your file reveals is not the
case).

The lines complaining about EXTRA references are because my script
non-discriminately slurps up ALL tags that have any attribute osisID.
So it's gobbling up all of your notes as well, which are not going to
be found in a versification scheme anywhere because of the !o372 type
of additions. To clean that up, let's have you change line 52 in your
branch to
ids = d("verse[osisID]")
That should limit it to only picking up "verse" elements instead of
ALL elements.

Outside of that, I can't see what you've changed in the script because
you managed to change just about every single line in your zeal to
achieve PEP-8 compliance so I can't begin to comment on whether the
problems are with my original logic or with your changes.

--Greg

On Mon, Aug 24, 2015 at 2:47 PM, Matěj Cepl <mcepl at cepl.eu> wrote:
> On 2015-08-24, 18:21 GMT, Greg Hellings wrote:
>> Specifically: http://crosswire.org/svn/sword-tools/trunk/versification/av11n.py
>
> I have found it and start to work on it (it didn’t work out of
> the box). My current branch (with PEP8ification, and changes
> I found needed) is at the git repo
> https://gitlab.com/mcepl/sword-tools branch fix_av11n_py.
> However, with all this and using OSIS source for my module
> CzeCSP (that's http://mcepl.fedorapeople.org/tmp/bible.xml.gz)
> I get this not very helpful information:
>
> $ ./av11n.py bible.xml
> Checking Catholic
>         There are 27543 OT IDs and 7959 NT IDs in the versification which are not in your file.
>         Your file has no extra references
> Checking Catholic2
>         There are 27651 OT IDs and 7959 NT IDs in the versification which are not in your file.
>         Your file has no extra references
> Checking German
>         There are 23215 OT IDs and 7957 NT IDs in the versification which are not in your file.
>         Your file has no extra references
> Checking KJV
>         There are 23145 OT IDs and 7957 NT IDs in the versification which are not in your file.
>         Your file has no extra references
> Checking KJVA
>         There are 28862 OT IDs and 7957 NT IDs in the versification which are not in your file.
>         Your file has no extra references
> Checking Leningrad
>         There are 23213 OT IDs and 0 NT IDs in the versification which are not in your file.
>         Your file has no extra references
> Checking Luther
>         There are 27812 OT IDs and 7957 NT IDs in the versification which are not in your file.
>         Your file has no extra references
> Checking MT
>         There are 23213 OT IDs and 0 NT IDs in the versification which are not in your file.
>         Your file has no extra references
> Checking NRSV
>         There are 23145 OT IDs and 7959 NT IDs in the versification which are not in your file.
>         Your file has no extra references
> Checking NRSVA
>         There are 29832 OT IDs and 7959 NT IDs in the versification which are not in your file.
>         Your file has no extra references
> Checking Rahlfs
>         There are 31390 OT IDs and 0 NT IDs in the versification which are not in your file.
>         Your file has no extra references
> Checking Synodal
>         There are 29144 OT IDs and 7955 NT IDs in the versification which are not in your file.
>         Your file has no extra references
> Checking Vulg
>         There are 27863 OT IDs and 9392 NT IDs in the versification which are not in your file.
>         Your file has no extra references
> $
>
> Any idea, why the script completely missed whatever is in my
> file. AFAIK, it is a correct OSIS file which was used (in its
> previous version) for the Sword CzeCSP module and works just
> fine.
>
> Thanks,
>
> Matěj
>
> --
> http://www.ceplovi.cz/matej/, Jabber: mcepl at ceplovi.cz
> GPG Finger: 89EF 4BC6 288A BF43 1BAB  25C3 E09F EF25 D964 84AC
>
> Always make new mistakes
>    -- Esther Dyson
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> sword-devel mailing list: sword-devel at crosswire.org
> http://www.crosswire.org/mailman/listinfo/sword-devel
> Instructions to unsubscribe/change your settings at above page