[osis-users] Some more footnote questions - more osisIDs and osisRefs on notes

[Chris Little]

These two and case 3 should perhaps have been combined, but I'll respond 
just to affirm that these are just additional instances of the same 
issue. Put the verses that a note refers to in osisRef. And put 
something like the verse in which they appear plus "!note" in the osisID.

Examples below....

On 2/21/2013 7:32 AM, Markku Pihlaja wrote:
> *Case 4) As in 3), but the note explains two (really) separate verses
> instead of a contiguous range.*
>
> Exod.33.19 and Exod.34.5 both talk about "Jahve", and the footnote
> explains that name. However, the asterisk is only in 33.19. In a print
> Bible, the footnote for 33.19 at the bottom of the page mentions both
> verses.

<note osisID="Exod.33.19!note" osisRef="Exod.33.19 Exod.34.5">...</note>

> Also, a footnote for Rom.1.1 and Rom.1.7 (marked by an asterisk only at
> 1.7) explains that the beginning of 1.7 has been moved to end of 1.1.

<note osisID="Rom.1.7!note" osisRef="Rom.1.7">...</note>
(I don't see this as a note about Rom.1.1, but add that to the osisRef 
if it is deemed to be about Rom.1.1.)

> *Case 5) The asterisk for the footnote is inside a title before (and
> outside) the actual verse or range it refers to.*
>
>     <title type="sub" level="4">Uudenvuodenjuhla*</title>
>     <p><verse sID="3. Moos. 23:23" osisID="Lev.23.23" />Herra sanoi
>     Moosekselle:<verse eID="3. Moos. 23:23" />...
>
>
> I guess this is a trivial case, just checking: I'd use osisID
> "Lev.23.23!note" and osisRef that indicates the range that the note
> refers to.

<note osisID="Lev.23.23!note" osisRef="Lev.23.23">...</note>

Alternately, you could put an osisID on the title element itself and 
have something like:
<title type="sub" level="4" osisID="Lev.23.23!title">Uudenvuodenjuhla
<note osisID="Lev.23.23!title.note" osisRef="Lev.23.23!title">***</note>
</title>

or, if the title is not part of the verse, only part of the chapter:

<title type="sub" level="4" osisID="Lev.23!title2">Uudenvuodenjuhla
<note osisID="Lev.23!title2.note" osisRef="Lev.23!title2">***</note>
</title>


--Chris