[osis-core] Encoding of Bible.TEV:Matt.13.1-Matt.13.23

[Todd Tillinghast]

What I attached is what I was/am proposing as an acceptable encoding.  

What I was trying to demonstrate in the text of posting was that in a
large number of cases there will be an intersection between verses and
lines in a lineGroup.  If either a line element could act as a "sub
class" of verse or if there were a way to allow a verse to exist within
a lineGroup and contain lines then the encoding job would be much
simpler.  It is possible to define a special verse element that is only
a child of lineGroup that is identical to the "normal" verse element but
also allows line elements as children.

It think that we will find that encoding lineGroups and possibly lists
to be much less onerous with this sort of mechanism.

Todd

> -----Original Message-----
> From: owner-osis-core@bibletechnologieswg.org [mailto:owner-osis-
> core@bibletechnologieswg.org] On Behalf Of Kees F. de Blois
> Sent: Monday, July 08, 2002 3:52 AM
> To: osis-core@bibletechnologieswg.org
> Subject: RE: [osis-core] Encoding of Bible.TEV:Matt.13.1-Matt.13.23
> 
> Todd,
> 
> I hope that what you are proposing is acceptable. I thought it would,
> since there are no embedded paragraphs with quotes within vs 15.....
> 
> Kees
> 
> > -----Original Message-----
> > From: owner-osis-core@bibletechnologieswg.org
> > [mailto:owner-osis-core@bibletechnologieswg.org] On Behalf Of
> > Todd Tillinghast
> > Sent: 07 July 2002 21:09
> > To: osis-core@bibletechnologieswg.org
> > Subject: [osis-core] Encoding of Bible.TEV:Matt.13.1-Matt.13.23
> >
> >
> > I have encoded Bible.TEV:Matt.13.1-Matt.13.23.
> >
> > This had the nasty cases of overlapping heirarchies discussed
> > previously.
> >
> > The one block quote is split accross several paragraphs and
> > there several verses broken accross lines (see Matt.13.15).
> >
> > It seems to me that
> > <lineGroup>
> >     <line><verse osisID="Matt.13.14@char:44(This)"
> > prev="Matt.13.14">This people will listen and listen, but not
> > understand;</verse></line>
> >     <line><verse osisID="Matt.13.14@char:102(they)"
> > prev="Matt.13.14@char:44(This)">they will look and look, but
> > not see,</verse></line>
> >     <line><verse osisID="Matt.13.15"
> > next="Matt.13.15@char:10">because their minds are
dull,</verse></line>
> >     <line><verse osisID="Matt.13.15@char:10"
> > prev="Matt.13.15" next="Matt.13.15@char:20">and they have
> > stopped up their ears</verse></line>
> >     <line><verse osisID="Matt.13.15@char:20"
> > prev="Matt.13.15@char:10" next="Matt.13.15@char:30">and have
> > closed their eyes.</verse></line>
> >     <line><verse osisID="Matt.13.15@char:30"
> > prev="Matt.13.15@char:20"
> > next="Matt.13.15@char:40">Otherwise, their eyes would
> > see,</verse></line>
> >     <line><verse osisID="Matt.13.15@char:40"
> > prev="Matt.13.15@char:30" next="Matt.13.15@char:50">their
> > ears would hear,</verse></line>
> >     <line><verse osisID="Matt.13.15@char:50"
> > prev="Matt.13.15@char:40" next="Matt.13.15@char:60">their
> > minds would understand,</verse></line>
> >     <line><verse osisID="Matt.13.15@char:60"
> > prev="Matt.13.15@char:50" next="Matt.13.15@char:70">and they
> > would turn to me, says God,</verse></line>
> >     <line><verse osisID="Matt.13.15@char:70"
> > prev="Matt.13.15@char:60">and I would heal
> > them.</verse></line> </lineGroup> is sort of ugly. Would be
> > much cleaner as <lineGroup>
> >     <verse osisID="Matt.13.14@char:44(This)" prev="Matt.13.14">
> >         <line>This people will listen and listen, but not
> > understand;</line>
> >         <line>they will look and look, but not see,</line>
> >     </verse>
> >     <verse osisID="Matt.13.15">
> >         <line>because their minds are dull,</line>
> >         <line>and they have stopped up their ears</line>
> >         <line>and have closed their eyes.</line>
> >         <line>Otherwise, their eyes would see,</line>
> >         <line>their ears would hear,</line>
> >         <line>their minds would understand,/line>
> >         <line>and they would turn to me, says God,</line>
> >         <line>and I would heal them.</line>
> >     </verse>
> > </lineGroup>
> >
> > Todd
> >
>