[osis-core] rich example

Fri, 05 Apr 2002 01:57:18 -0700

> I know this is not what you are after with the rich example but looking at
> the richness of the example points out the fact that it is unlikely that any
> document will include ALL of the possible <w> type elements.

I'm not exactly sure what you mean with this comment?  Are you saying 
that my example is unlikely?  I'm actually about to produce a few 
complete texts marked up exactly like this.

I would still appreciate your comments on the actual example, as I KNOW 
I don't have the linking between the 2 correct and was hoping for your 
comments soon.

	-Troy.

> Any ideas on how we could represent the <w> elements in a separate document
> that are not included in the scripture document itself?
> 
> Todd
> ----- Original Message -----
> From: "Troy A. Griffitts" <scribe@crosswire.org>
> To: <osis-core@bibletechnologieswg.org>
> Sent: Thursday, April 04, 2002 7:02 PM
> Subject: Re: [osis-core] rich example
> 
> 
> 
>>New cut at the bottom...
>>
>>
>>>Don't turn the crank just yet! With the XMLSpy missing some fairly
>>>important stuff, I want to make a pass with the IBM schema validator and
>>>walk through an (gasp!) analog copy tonight/early tomorrow.
>>>
>>:)
>>
>>Good luck!
>>
>>
>>
>>><verseStart VerseStart="John.1.1"
>>>reference="HarperBibleCommentary.1988.p.1046">
>>>
>>>Possible, in which case we would probably want to allow several such
>>>references. Hmmm, may not be the best way.
>>>
>>>Originally, we discussed reference as a linking mechanism for other
>>>milestones and it just got put on verses without a lot of thought (on my
>>>part).
>>>
>>>Comments from the group?
>>>
>>I would think the link would go the other way: commentary -> Bible
>>
>>Is it normal to have an attribute called the same as its element?  might
>>we remove VerseStart and keep reference?  It might be easier to write
>>code if we have the same attribute for all these type of milestone tags:
>><chapterStart /> <verseStart /> <bookStart /> <chapterEnd /> <verseEnd
>>/> <bookEnd />
>>
>>
>>>My inclination is to take reference off of the verse milestones. There
>>>are better ways to link to other materials. That would leave references
>>>on the other milestones (although not as ID datatype!) to point to
>>>beginning and ending material in the milestones.
>>>
>>
>>
>>
>>Latest cut:
>>____________________
>>
>>
>>TR: en arXA An ho logos kai ho logos An pros ton Qeon kai Qeos An ho
>>logos
>>KJV: In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the
>>Word was God.
>>
>>becomes:
>>
>>
>>TR:
>>
>><bookStart BookStart="John" /><chapterStart ChapterStart="John.1"
>>/><verseStart VerseStart="John.1.1" /><w lemma="x-Strong:1722"
>>morphology="x-Robinson:PREP" gloss="x-en:In"
>>transliteration="x-Latin:en" ID="trw67521">en</w> <w
>>lemma="x-Strong:746" morphology="x-Robinson:N-DSF" gloss="x-en:the
>>beginning" transliteration="x-Latin:archei" ID="trw67522">arXa</w> <w
>>lemma="x-Strong:2258" morphology="x-Robinson:V-IXI-3S" gloss="x-en:was"
>>transliteration="x-Latin:ein" ID="trw67523">An</w> <w
>>lemma="x-Strong:3056" morphology="x-Robinson:N-NSM" gloss="x-en:the
>>Word" transliteration="x-Latin:ho logos" ID="trw67524">ho logos</w>, <w
>>lemma="x-Strong:2532" morphology="x-Robinson:CONJ" gloss="x-en:and"
>>transliteration="x-Latin:kai" ID="trw67525">kai</w> <w
>>lemma="x-Strong:3056" morphology="x-Robinson:N-NSM" gloss="x-en:the
>>Word" transliteration="x-Latin:ho logos" ID="trw67526">ho logos</w> <w
>>lemma="x-Strong:2258" morphology="x-Robinson:V-IXI-3S" gloss="x-en:was"
>>transliteration="x-Latin:ein" ID="trw67527">An</w> <w
>>lemma="x-Strong:4314" morphology="x-Robinson:PREP" gloss="x-en:with"
>>transliteration="x-Latin:pros" ID="trw67528">pros</w> <w
>>lemma="x-Strong:2316" morphology="x-Robinson:N-ASM" gloss="x-en:God"
>>tranliteration="ton theon" ID="trw67529">ton Qeon</w>, <w
>>lemma="x-Strong:2532" morphology="x-Robinson:CONJ" gloss="x-en:and"
>>transliteration="x-Latin:kai" ID="trw67530">kai</w> <w
>>lemma="x-Strong:2316" morphology="x-Robinson:N-NSM gloss="x-en:God"
>>transliteration="x-Latin:theos" ID="trw67531">Qeos</w> <w
>>lemma="x-Strong:2258" morphology="x-Robinson:V-IXI-3S" gloss="x-en:was"
>>transliteration="x-Latin:ein" ID="trw67532">An</w> <w
>>lemma="x-Strong:3056" morphology="x-Robinson:N-NSM" gloss="x-en:the
>>Word" transliteration="x-Latin:ho logos" ID="trw67533">ho
>>logos</w><verseEnd refVerseStart="John.1.1" />
>>
>>KJV:
>>
>><bookStart BookStart="John" /><chapterStart ChapterStart="John.1"
>>/><verseStart VerseStart="John.1.1" /><w lemma="x-Strong:1722"
>>morphology="x-Robinson:PREP" reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67521">In</w> <w
>>lemma="x-Strong:746" morphology="x-Robinson:N-DSF"
>>reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67522">the beginning</w> <w
>>lemma="x-Strong:2258" morphology="x-Robinson:V-IXI-3S"
>>reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67523">was</w> <w lemma="x-Strong:3056"
>>morphology="x-Robinson:N-NSM" reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67524">the
>>Word</w>, <w lemma="x-Strong:2532" morphology="x-Robinson:CONJ"
>>reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67525">and</w> <w lemma="x-Strong:3056"
>>morphology="x-Robinson:N-NSM" reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67526">the
>>Word</w> <w lemma="x-Strong:2258" morphology="x-Robinson:V-IXI-3S"
>>reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67527">was</w> <w lemma="x-Strong:4314"
>>morphology="x-Robinson:PREP" reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67528">with</w>
>><w lemma="x-Strong:2316" morphology="x-Robinson:N-ASM"
>>reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67529">God</w>, <w lemma="x-Strong:2532"
>>morphology="x-Robinson:CONJ" reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67530">and</w> <w
>>lemma="x-Strong:3056" morphology="x-Robinson:N-NSM
>>reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67533">the Word</w> <w lemma="x-Strong:2258"
>>morphology="x-Robinson:V-IXI-3S"
>>reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67532">was</w> <w lemma="x-Strong:2316"
>>morphology="x-Robinson:N-NSM
>>reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67531">God</w>.<verseEnd
>>refVerseStart="John.1.1" />
>>